Best Bumper Plates for Your Home Gym

This post contatins affliliate links. If you click on one of these links and then make a purchase from the linked advertiser, I’ll make a commission at no extra cost to you. Click Here to read my Privacy Policy and Affiliate Disclosure.

Click here to skip buying guide and go straight to reviews

Table of Contents

Intro

You just saved $300-400 Buckaroos by buying one of the squat racks in our guide Best Affordable Squat Racks for 2019

You got yourself a bar also: Best Affordable Olympic Barbells

You got a bench: Best Flat Benches for Your Home Gym

You even got a great deal on some used Olymplic plates by reading Apps to Find Used Home Gym Equipment

But then you realize you are missing something…

You are missing the ability to bounce your weights.

You are missing…Bumper Plates!

Do you need Bumper Plates?

So if you pay attention to the marketing material on r/homegym you would think that its mandatory to have a set of bumper plates. 🙂

Who needs Bumper Plates?

  • Beggining deadlifters who are not yet strong enough to lift two 45s off the ground
  • lifters who are going to be doing the Olymplic Lifts
  • Those who need extra protection for their floors

Are Bumper Plates quieter than metal plates?

Honestly its arguable. I have had mine since 2016 and they can be loud as hell. Some people even believe they are louder than metal plates on a good material like horse stall mats: https://startingstrength.com/resources/forum/general-q-and-a/79820-budget-bumper-plates.html#post1662249

Why do I have Bumper Plates?

Honestly because I am an idiot.

Well, maybe because I got some for a decent price. Also when I was starting out I wanted to deadlift from the proper height but wasn’t yet strong enough to get two 45 pound plates off the ground. So getting a set of bumper plates was a great option for me.

Crumb vs Regular Black Rubber Bumper Plates

Crumb Bumper Plates:

  • Made from recycled Rubber
  • Can be more durable than regular black
  • Often Bounce more than regular black rubber plates

Regular Black Rubber Bumper Plates

  • Bounce less (Which can be a good thing)
  • More readily available

To see what I mean, watch this video:

So I tend to steer people toward the Black Rubber Bumper Plates but really its up to you. Check out the material section of each of our reviews to see what the item is made out of.

Will they bounce away?

This is a big problem that no one talks about. To combat this I always keep my Bumper Plates on a leash. 🙂

Reviews

#1 – OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plate Set

OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plates

OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Made of dense, solid rubber with hooked steel inserts for durability.
Colors : Black
Warranty : 365 day satisfaction guarantee with FREE returns
Durability Info : Whereas most companies only test their bumpers for 15,000 drops, all of our bumpers have been tested for 30,000 drops, even the 10s! Proven tough, you can perform your olympic lifts, squats, and deadlifts safely and confidently with our tough olympic bumper plates.

Looking for the best bumper plates for your home gym? The OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plates are the ones you should be looking at right away. How am I so sure? Well, I’ve had them for the past 3 years and they are perfect till this date. Even though I was careless and stored them in a humid garage for a lengthy amount of time, the OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plates endured and still look and work like brand new. So personally, I would wholeheartedly recommend these to anyone looking for the best bumper plates.

However, you are not going to purchase stuff on my word alone right? You need features and OneFitWonder 160 Lbs Bumper Plates has them in abundance. The plate comes in pairs of 45, 25 and 10-pound and is made of sturdy rubber with hooked steel inserts that provide exceptional durability. One awesome thing about these plates is they don’t produce an odor, that’s right, they won’t be stinking up your home at all. The bumpers are also designed to keep your floor safe, so even if your hand slips (be safe please), the bumpers will keep your floor relatively safer. The bumpers have been tested for 30000 drops as well so you know you are going to get a great performer. The company is so sure about their product that they are offering a full year of satisfaction guarantee with free returns.

Pros: 

  • Superior durability that’s tested with 30k drops
  • Awesome guarantee
  • Made with thick, solid rubber
  • Has hooked steel inserts for better strength

Cons: 

  • The center holes can be a bit tight
  • The lack of lip makes them a bit hard to move around

Summary: The sturdiest plates that will endure for a long time  

#2 – Rep Fitness Bumper Plates

Rep Fitness Bumper Plates

Rep Fitness Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : 100% rubber bumper plates
Colors : Black
Warranty : 3 year warranty on 45, 35, 25 lb plates for home use, 1 year for commercial use. 1 year warranty on 10, 15 lb plates for home use, 6 months for commercial use.
Durability Info : These garage gym bumper plates are factory tested to withstand over 15000 drops from a height of 8 ft. Specially formulated to be durable with a low-bounce.

Rep Fitness Bumper Plates are some of the best quality plates I’ve tested. That’s not why they are in the second place though, it’s because of their super-reasonable pricing. They are priced perfectly and provide great value for your money. The 190 pound set of plates include pairs of 45, 25, 15 and 10-pound plates. These days a great set of bumper plates is almost essential in a well-rounded workout and the Rep Fitness Bumper Plates provide exactly that without breaking your bank.

The Rep Fitness Bumper Plates comes with a sturdy rubber with steel inserts. The plates fit an Olympic bar without any problems. I really love how the company made the 10-pound plates a bit thicker so they are a lot durable while the 45-pound plates are kept thinner so you can really stack the bar. The weights are low odor as well, so you don’t have to worry about any rubbery stink in your home gym. The Rep Fitness Bumper Plates comes with a 3-year warranty for home use as well.

Pros: 

  • Thicker 10 lbs. plates while 45 are thin
  • Rubber is of good quality
  • Tested with 15,000 drops
  • 3 year home use warranty

Cons: 

  • Despite the low odor claim, they smell
  • The packaging needs a tiny bit of improvement

Summary: Awesome company, great quality bumper plates  

#3 – ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES

ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES

ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Solid Rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : 10-15LB variant plates are warrantied for 90 days. The 25-45 LBS variants are warrantied for 3 years.
Durability Info : score an average of 88 on the Shore A Durometer scale

If you are in the market for some awesome quality bumper plates, you simply cannot ignore ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES. They are well designed and have an incredibly consistent bounce. Yeah, you read that right, I bounced them off the floor myself and was surprised to see how constant the bounce was. Not that it matters much if the overall product is not that great, thankfully the rest of ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES are just as well designed.

From the new artwork that is close to old school and still looks great to exceptional durability, the ROGUE HG 2.0 BUMPER PLATES provides everything you’d want in your bumper plates. Stainless steel inserts? Check, durable rubber? Check, great design? Check. The reasonably priced plates are 450mm in diameter which is complaint with IWF standards. They are also a bit thinner so you can load more of them on the bar if you want.

Pros: 

  • Thin yet sturdy weights
  • Stainless steel inserts provide exceptional strength
  • Low and consistent bounce
  • Stylish design

Cons: 

  • Shipping can be a bit expensive
  • They are a bit greasy in start

Summary: Style with substance  

#4 – Vulcan Strength 160LB BUMPER PLATE SET

Vulcan Strength 160LB BUMPER PLATE SET

Vulcan Strength 160LB BUMPER PLATE SET

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Solid Rubber weights made from virgin rubber not recycled rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : 1 year Warranty on Vulcan Bumper Plates (10lb and 15lb) . 36 Month Warranty on Vulcan Bumper Plates (25lb, 35lb, 45lb, and 55lb)
Durability Info : Our plates have been tested to 30,000 drops from a height of 9 feet without any deformation of the insert or damage to the rubber surface.

The Vulcan Strength 160LB BUMPER PLATE SET is made from brand new virgin rubber and not recycled ones. This means the bumper plate set avoids the “tire” like smell that comes from recycled rubber. Some people claim that virgin rubber has more bounce to it, I’ve never tested that out myself so not sure. The Vulcan Strength 160LB set does have consistently low bounce though, that much I’ve tested. One great thing about the Vulcan Strength 160LB weight set is that is tested by being dropped 30,000 times from a height of 9 feet. The plates didn’t see any deformation, damage to the inserts or change in the rubber surface. So you’ll be getting some of the strongest bumper plate sets with forged stainless steel inside.

Pros: 

Made with virgin rubber Steel inserts are forged Low profile plates so you can fit more on a bar Tested with 30,000 drops

Cons: 

The plates are a tad bit thicker than competitors The shipping price chart is daunting

Summary: Low odor, high quality  

#5 – ROGUE BUMPER PLATES BY HI-TEMP

ROGUE BUMPER PLATES BY HI-TEMP

ROGUE BUMPER PLATES BY HI-TEMP

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Made in the USA from Crumb Rubber (Recycled Vulcanized Rubber)
Colors : Black
Warranty : 1 Year
Durability Info : Durometer: 75

Looking for some premium quality bumper plates for your home gym? The ROGUE BUMPER PLATES BY HI-TEMP are a great candidate. With their superior sturdiness and great design, the bumper plates offer a lot to the users. One of the best things about the ROGUE BUMPER PLATES BY HI-TEMP is that it is made in Alabama, USA. They are made from extremely durable vulcanized rubber and has a 2-inch stainless steel insert. The downside is that the whole process can leave some surface-level aesthetic imperfections in the plates, however, the overall quality is never compromised. The design offers a collar that can lock properly and decreases the risk of them popping out.

Pros: 

Has 2-inch stainless steel inserts Collar design on the inserts Great quality crumb rubber Comes with a 1-year warranty

Cons: 

The bumper plates smell a bit The price can be high for many customers

Summary: Premium materials with the price to match  

#6 – Rep Fitness Colored Bumper Plates

Rep Fitness Colored Bumper Plates

Rep Fitness Colored Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Solid Rubber with Steel Insert
Colors : Gray (10 lb), Green (25 lb), Blue (45 lb)
Warranty : 1 year warranty on 10’s and 15’s, 3 years on 25’s, 35’s, 45’s, 55’s for home use
Durability Info : Factory tested to withstand over 15,000 drops from a height of 8 ft

Rep Fitness Colored Bumper Plates as the name suggests come in multiple colors. If you are tired of the same old black-colored bumper plates, these are the ones you should look at. While I really wanted to get the bright green, I settled for the subtle blue at the end. Have to say, they really do look great and are a pleasant departure from the usual black we see. The plates themselves are made from solid rubber with a steel insert. The 10-pound plates are thicker to increase durability while the 45 are kept thin so you can stack more of them on the bar. The rubber used on the Rep Fitness Colored Bumper Plates also has low bounce, so your bar won’t bunny hop into a mirror. The plates are tested to endure over 15000 drops from 8ft which is fairly great in our books.

Pros: 

The plates have colors! Good quality design Tested with 15,000 drops Reasonable warranty period

Cons: 

The rubber plates can smell quite a bit The yellow color is way brighter than it looks in the photos

Summary: Get some colors on that Olympic bar  

#7 – XMark Go Green Bumper Plates

XMark Go Green Bumper Plates

XMark Go Green Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : 3 Years for Personal Use, 1 year for commerical
Durability Info : Go Green manufacturing process gives the bumpers a little more bounce; but they will take more abuse and last twice as long as any other bumper. Rubber, by its very nature, is tough and durable.

The XMark Go Green Bumper Plates are specifically designed to withstand drops. They are made with the Go Green manufacturing process that gives the bumpers a bit more bounciness. This extra bounce helps the plates to absorb more force, withstand abuse and last twice as long as other bumpers on the market. The rubber used on the XMark Go Green Bumper Plates is naturally durable as well so you won’t have to worry about replacing them after a few years of usage either. The precision-tooled stainless steel inserts allow the plate to easily slide on bars. The XMark Go Green Bumper Plates also come with a 3 year home warranty, which is a nice bonus.

Pros: 

Extra bouncy to endure more drops The precision-tooled steel plates are great Comes with a 3-year warranty Great material quality

Cons: 

The bounciness can be annoying for some The plates definitely smell a lot

Summary: Don’t worry about drops, they can handle it  

#8 – Titan 230 lb Set of Olympic Bumper Plates

Titan 230 lb Set of Olympic Bumper Plates

Titan 230 lb Set of Olympic Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 230
Weights Included : 2×45,2×35,2×20,2×10
Material : Rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : Not Listed
Durability Info : Thick rubber plate is very durable; Steel internal ring is heavy duty and maintains shape

In the market for a thick rubber bumper plate? The Titan 230 lb Set of Olympic Bumper Plates is one of the best ones around. The bumper plates can easily fit any Olympic bar you want to use. The plates can also be used on 2-inch dumbbell bars which is a huge plus. The thick rubber used in the construction is durable and strong. The internet ring is made with heavy-duty steel and will maintain its shape even after repeated drops. The set includes 4 pairs of bumper plates of 10, 25, 35 and 45 pounds. Overall the Titan 230 lb Set of Olympic Bumper Plates is a great choice if you need thicker rubber plates.

Pros: 

The inner steel ring is highly durable The rubber is thick and strong Can be used on dumbbell bars Overall good quality

Cons: 

Will smell for a while Packaging needs a bit of improvement

Summary: Thick rubber, thicker gains  

#9 – XMark Hi-Impact Bumper Plates

XMark Hi-Impact Bumper Plates

XMark Hi-Impact Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : 3 Years for Personal Use, 1 year for commerical
Durability Info : Hi-Impact bumpers that are specially engineered for dropping. Rubber, by its very nature, is tough and durable.

The XMark Hi-Impact Bumper Plates are made to be dropped, that’s not just a tag line, and they are indeed engineered to withstand drops. The rubber used is already sturdy enough to endure drops but the XMark Hi-Impact Bumper Plates takes it a bit further with their technology. The commercial-grade 2-inch stainless steel insert allows the plates to be easily mounted on the bar. No need to push and shove the plates on your bars anymore, they fit easily.

Pros: 

High-quality rubber is used The steel insert is strong Comes with a 3-year warranty 10-pound plates are smaller and stronger

Cons: 

The smell will stay for a while They will be oily in the start, you’ll need to keep a wipe

Summary: Born to be dropped  

#10 – X Training Equipment Premium Black Bumper Plates

X Training Equipment Premium Black Bumper Plates

X Training Equipment Premium Black Bumper Plates

Total Pounds in Set : 160
Weights Included : 2×45,2×25,2×10
Material : Solid Rubber
Colors : Black
Warranty : 10lb and 15lb plates are covered for six months. 25lb, 35lb, and 45lb plates are covered for three years.
Durability Info : Designed for low bounce and high durability, X Training odorless bumpers are constructed of 100% solid rubber to withstand punishment during any strength training or fitness workout from deadlift to max rep lifts.

The X Training Equipment Premium Black Bumper Plates is the budget offering on the list. While it is not as expensive as other bumper plates, it is certainly on par with them in terms of quality. The plates are made for maximum durability and low bounce, this is thanks to its 100% solid rubber construction. The bumper plates can fit any standard 2-inch Olympic barbell as well. The X Training Equipment Premium Black Bumper Plates also comes with 6 months of warranty for the 10 and 15-pound plates while the 25, 35 and 45 ones get 3 years of it.

Pros: 

Standard equipment Made with solid rubber Has an inner steel ring
Low bounce material

Cons: 

The bounce might be too low for some The ring can be improved

Summary: Easy on the wallet and the floor  

Wrap Up

So that is all we have for our guide to the Best Bumper Plates for Your Home Gym. As usual please reach out to us in the comments if we got something wrong or to let us know your opinion or even just to say hi!

Leave a Comment